• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Reporteev

News, reviews and more!

Ad example
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Film
  • Music

What defines a proper garden? – The Guardian

July 25, 2021 by Gardening

One of the most common put-downs I hear in horticulture is that something isn’t a “proper garden”. As a botanist who studies our cultural relationship with plants, and a designer who has created gardens for the Chelsea Flower Show, I have yet to pinpoint what this term actually means. In the interests of getting it right, lets take a closer look.

In some definitions, a garden is a piece of land that adjoins a house in which plants may be grown. But this view would exclude anything that isn’t a domestic dwelling – from every allotment in the country, to some of the world’s most famous botanical gardens. Even if we gloss over the “house” part, as other definitions do, we are still left with the stipulation of a garden as “piece of land”. Does that mean that roof gardens – such as the spectacular sky parks of Singapore, where palm-filled rainforests are lifted towards the clouds – don’t count? If they aren’t gardens, then the living walls clinging to the sides of buildings that are cropping up in cities all over the world aren’t either. What about miniature gardens, where entire landscapes are shrunk down in trays, glass terrariums and even enclosed tanks? Absolutely no land – often not even soil – is involved in these, so perhaps they are not “gardens” in the true sense of the word?

Small but perfectly formed: a terrarium. Photograph: Nicholas Eveleigh/Alamy

Do gardens even really need to contain plants at all? I would be tempted to say yes they do, until you consider the centuries-old Zen gravel gardens of Japan, or the modernist wonders of water and architectural concrete created by Brazil’s Roberto Burle Marx, one of the world’s most famous 20th-century garden designers. Where do we draw the line?

Perhaps the best way to answer this is to move beyond definitions of the term in the English language, which will inevitably come with some language and cultural bias, and look at examples of gardens from history to see what they all have in common. While most horticultural texts will tell you that concept of the garden as a landscape designed exclusively for pleasure, not food production, can be traced back to the Middle East, this is only true of the western garden style. In reality, just like agriculture, the concept of ornamental horticulture appears to have arisen independently across unconnected civilisations. From the floating gardens of the Aztecs set amid a vast lake to the manicured miniature landscapes of rocks and rivers created in ancient China, to the range of ritual ornamental plants carefully selected by indigenous peoples from Papua New Guinea to New Zealand, the desire to garden seems almost universal.

The one thing they have in common is that they are stylised landscapes that – whether we know it or not – depict nature the way we think it “should” be. In fact, I’d argue that gardens are probably the best barometer of how a culture sees nature and humanity’s place in it: the physical embodiment of what the world around us “should” look like. The wonderful thing is, of course, that this is entirely in the eye of their creators.

So what is a “proper” garden? Anything you want it to be – and anyone who tells you differently is simply betraying how little they know about gardens.

Follow James on Twitter @Botanygeek

Filed Under: Gardening Tagged With: RSS Feeds

Primary Sidebar

More To See

Peloton recalls two million bikes over injury risk

npressfetimg-44.png

3 Persistent Photography Myths. When you’ve been doing … – Medium

npressfetimg-43.png

Meeting Napa’s Mr Fix-it – Wine-Searcher

npressfetimg-42.png

Exclusive: John Fetterman Is Using This Assistive Technology in the Senate to Help With His Stroke Recovery – TIME

Business

npressfetimg-1030.png

What’s next for the business of longevity? – The New York Times

npressfetimg-1017.png

Women in Business: Choices, sacrifices involved in running a business – Daily Record-News

npressfetimg-1012.png

Openings & Closings: Business news around the area – WFMZ Allentown

npressfetimg-999.png

BUSINESS BUZZ: Fatty C’s establishing itself within Big Rapids community – The Pioneer

More Posts from this Category

Technology

npressfetimg-1092.png

China accuses Washington of wanting ‘technology hegemony’ – The Associated Press – en Español

npressfetimg-1061.png

Back from extinction: Resurrecting the Tasmanian tiger | Science and Technology – Al Jazeera English

npressfetimg-1055.png

Bandwidth Challenges Limit Grocery Chains’ Technology Initiatives – The Wall Street Journal

npressfetimg-1050.png

BuzzFeed to use OpenAI technology to create content – CBS News

More Posts from this Category

Film

npressfetimg-1091.png

Which Sundance Movies Could Follow ‘CODA’ to the Oscars? – The New York Times

Over the past few decades, the Sundance Movie Festival has actually p…….

npressfetimg-1054.png

Top Gun: Maverick, one of the most “for grownups” movies ever, won AARP’s Movies For Grownups Award – Yahoo Entertainment

Top Weapon: Maverick

For two decades, AARP has actually made a point to cut through all of …….

npressfetimg-1049.png

HBO Max Schedule January 30-February 5: New TV & Movies – Yahoo Entertainment

The Hobbit: The Battle of the 5 Armies is back on HBO Max as part of the schedule for January 30-…….

npressfetimg-1041.png

10 ancient-Egypt facts TV and movies got wrong, according to an expert – Business Insider

Movies and television shape what people think about ancient Egypt.
However they typically get even…….

More Posts from this Category

Copyright © 2023 Reporteev